Even games and movies where they record their own SFX from scratch will sometimes pull from libraries here and there, so it’s entirely possible.
Aaronspark777
Who
WithKris
They most likely got it from the same audio library, doubt IW would waste there time making original Audio for all their guns when they can buy it from someone who already has it.
AsianET428
You would think the country this game came from would be able to record an AK.
onehappyfella
Honest question tho guys: who the fuck cares?
CmTributex
GOD BLESS RUSSIA
Psycho1267
Maybe, maybe not, fun game though.
orphan_clubber
Since there’s a lot of confusion here I think I have some authority to speak on that as someone has extracted and used the MW19 sounds for many mods for other games. Many of the sounds do infact come from an audio library. The ones that are “original” to the game are the firing sounds which use several layers of different effects.
The foley sounds are not original to MW19 and are licensed. This is obvious in part due to the metadata which lists separate info from many of the other sounds, and also that a co-author of mine identified the many sounds in several other games such as far cry and insurgency.
As an AK owner as well, part of what gives away the fact that IW didn’t record it themselves is that they used real guns to record the sounds and the sound in the video is not what an AK sounds like lol, but that’s sort of anecdotal
Very good hearing on the part of OP, but it’s simply not how game development works and the truth is that many assets that big studios use are from licensed libraries.
Ecstatic-Rutabaga850
Wait until COD players realize that sound banks exist
djJulioSanchez
You should compare the 2x samples in audacity and look at the waveforms to see if they overlap. Sounds very similar but the visuals would confirm it
TrippySubie
Wouldnt doubt it that IW used a sound from a library.
rozeskinuser_
nothing will beat the bo1 ak reload
Berkut22
If they didn’t, they wasted a lot of time and money to record their own, because it sounds exactly the same to me.
rukioish
OP learning what an audio library is.
Jamie7860
I also saw a clip of atomic heart having the same music as the Ghostface music in Dead by Daylight, don’t know what to make of this.
Friendly_Bot_
What kind of degent roleplay as the Wagner PMC online💀
Dreaminginslowmotion
Not an expert on audio IP, but would that be a legal issue between companies?
CHARLIE_3310
And also the Makarov shot sounds like M19
Smyek
Nice PR post from an account made exactly to promote atomic heart
toscanius
Y’all are surprised when its a Russian studio who supports the Russian genocide of Ukrainians. Ain’t gonna buy their game.
Paqaboll721
They also used the dead by daylight music. I swear, after the first boss, it plays.
Machotoast04098
Same Audio library
Krondon57
thought it was weird from the trailer but thought it was a placeholder????
V2sh1fty
Audio packs are a thing. Just like graphics packs. Game developers don’t sit there and create everything themselves all the time. You must be new to games. Just because they say they recorded a shit load of audio from “90 different mics” doesn’t mean they used exclusively that audio.
cantpickaname8
Don’t these companies just use Sound libraries for alot of the basic audio like this? There’s a pretty solid chance that both used the same Sound Library as others have commented.
33 Comments
What’s the problem if there’s a sound in soundbank
As if Atomic Heart is the first game to ever do this lmao
This Wikipedia article might bring some clarity
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stock_sound_effect
How did CoD players notice this, they don’t play single player games anymore.
What’s the other game you’re using as a reference?
honest question. if it’s the same gun, shouldn’t it sound the same or very similar?
But it’s the same gun isn’t it gonna sound the same? Like even if they made the sound themselves wouldn’t also have a high chance of being similar
Atomic grip
It’s possible that this particular sound effect comes from the same library:
https://www.boomlibrary.com/sound-effects/assault-weapons/
https://www.boomlibrary.com/blog/call-of-duty-modern-warfare/
Even games and movies where they record their own SFX from scratch will sometimes pull from libraries here and there, so it’s entirely possible.
Who
They most likely got it from the same audio library, doubt IW would waste there time making original Audio for all their guns when they can buy it from someone who already has it.
You would think the country this game came from would be able to record an AK.
Honest question tho guys: who the fuck cares?
GOD BLESS RUSSIA
Maybe, maybe not, fun game though.
Since there’s a lot of confusion here I think I have some authority to speak on that as someone has extracted and used the MW19 sounds for many mods for other games. Many of the sounds do infact come from an audio library. The ones that are “original” to the game are the firing sounds which use several layers of different effects.
The foley sounds are not original to MW19 and are licensed. This is obvious in part due to the metadata which lists separate info from many of the other sounds, and also that a co-author of mine identified the many sounds in several other games such as far cry and insurgency.
As an AK owner as well, part of what gives away the fact that IW didn’t record it themselves is that they used real guns to record the sounds and the sound in the video is not what an AK sounds like lol, but that’s sort of anecdotal
Very good hearing on the part of OP, but it’s simply not how game development works and the truth is that many assets that big studios use are from licensed libraries.
Wait until COD players realize that sound banks exist
You should compare the 2x samples in audacity and look at the waveforms to see if they overlap. Sounds very similar but the visuals would confirm it
Wouldnt doubt it that IW used a sound from a library.
nothing will beat the bo1 ak reload
If they didn’t, they wasted a lot of time and money to record their own, because it sounds exactly the same to me.
OP learning what an audio library is.
I also saw a clip of atomic heart having the same music as the Ghostface music in Dead by Daylight, don’t know what to make of this.
What kind of degent roleplay as the Wagner PMC online💀
Not an expert on audio IP, but would that be a legal issue between companies?
And also the Makarov shot sounds like M19
Nice PR post from an account made exactly to promote atomic heart
Y’all are surprised when its a Russian studio who supports the Russian genocide of Ukrainians. Ain’t gonna buy their game.
They also used the dead by daylight music. I swear, after the first boss, it plays.
Same Audio library
thought it was weird from the trailer but thought it was a placeholder????
Audio packs are a thing. Just like graphics packs. Game developers don’t sit there and create everything themselves all the time. You must be new to games. Just because they say they recorded a shit load of audio from “90 different mics” doesn’t mean they used exclusively that audio.
Don’t these companies just use Sound libraries for alot of the basic audio like this? There’s a pretty solid chance that both used the same Sound Library as others have commented.