This map continues to be replayable while nailing just about everything a zombies map needs to be successful. The only area it falls short is the side EEs, but other GOATed maps like Ancient Evil and Der Eisendrache also fall short in this area while exceeding at everything else. I wouldn't put Ashes any higher than the #10 spot exactly due to the maps above from BO2/3/4/IW simply being better as a whole