My first player, I honestly fought reed was going to stab me in the back so I decided to go with Songbird
My first player, I honestly fought reed was going to stab me in the back so I decided to go with Songbird
45 Comments
went with songbird
Ran phantom liberty 2 times, each time go with songbird
I always help Songbird, so Alex doesn’t die.
Then I give her to the Idris Elba guy (I forgot his name in the game), because she lied about curing V so there is no point in helping her anymore. Plus I don’t want to kill Idris Elba.
King of cups – side with reed, kill songbird.
Helped Songbird escape. What kind of monster wouldn’t help a songbird? Unless you’re a cat, of course.
Went with Reed. For one I was playing a netrunner and wanted the cyber deck. For two my V was a Corpo who agreed with reed. For three I wanted to see the scary section people were talking about.
Went with Songbird. Played as a nomad, was for “selfless help” all the way regardless of how she behaved.
Went with Songbird. Felt V could relate to Songbird’s situation, saw himself in her. Didn’t regret my choice.
I helped her and regretted it.
Songbird the first time but both are fantastic.
I think I mostly prefer siding with Reed though. As a horror fan I really like the Cynosure sequence and you also get a lot more background on Songbird. Plus you get what is in my opinion the best gun in the game.
I did both endings, but my Canon choice was to Side with Reed to ensure I could get the Erebus blueprint, but then let Songbird go so she would not be recaptured.
Saved Songbird 1st playthrough. Recently completed 2nd, King of Cups, much better.
I’m on my 2nd playthrough of Phantom Liberty right now. I will be siding with Reed this time
I helped Reed. Songbird’s freedom is one thing but being walking bomb is another thing. So regardless what I wanted to do next- disabling Blackwall in Songbird first sounded as better option
I didn’t trusted Songbird and I was glad about it after seeing what she did in the second playthrough
Songbird <3
Went with songbird before sending her off to reed during the killing moon.
Always with with Songbird. Fuck the NUSA
First playthrough as a street kid I helped Songbird and sent her to the moon. “You could have been honest at the start, woulda helped anyway.”
This time I’m a corpo and plan on siding with Reed, even though I know it means Alex dies.
Just finished it yesterday. I sided with songbird because she was sort of in a similar situation. But yeh was betrayed🤣 then gave her to reed
Went with Songbird the entire way. At first it was because I thought she was more likely to get me cured. Later it was because I figured I was already this close to getting her into that rocket that I might as well finish the job. Also Reed pulled a gun on me, so screw that guy.
Paused the game for roughly half an hour, hoping that when I unpaused it, the game would have progressed and not made me choose
I betrayed song as I knew she was running a game… that was a very poor decision…
I picked Reed but then saw what happened when tricking her and was so shocked that I reloaded and went the opposite way. Next time I’ll go through with Reed’s plan. It’s a bloodbath either way.
Go all the way with Songbird, it really feels like V and Songbird are on the same state, and my V was radicalized against the govt and corps by Johnny
Went with Reed cause I wanted to do the spooky underground part.
Also I liked Reed.
I need to run it again with song bird to the moon.
Reed is my boy 💪🏻
Songbird all the way. She owned up to it, and I believe she really is Vs best bet for an actual fix.
King of Cups. I would like to see the ending where you get healed, but I don’t have any save before I get to make the decision so I can’t bother playing the entire thing from the beginning.
Helped Songbird and then helped her escape. Second time I sided with her but then didn’t let her escape. This time didn’t side with her, but I haven’t yet completed the run.
Side with Reed, appoint Jago as new leader
First time I opted to side with reed. Going in blind I originally just wanted to see the cure ending for myself but when I reached the core I couldn’t follow through and mercy killed song.
First playthrough was my min max netrunner run so sided with Reed. Second time rescued SoMi and blasted Reed in his hypocritical face.
Always side with Songbird
Helped Reed and I enjoyed it a lot more than when I played the Songbird route later. It has the cooler missions and rewards. I also really enjoyed the King of Cups ending.
Went with Songbird. It felt like the more theatrical and canon thing to do, despite knowing she lied.
Certainly has nothing to do with not wanting to be chased by the spider.
First time I just went with Reed because I really thought he was going to help Songbird and I felt so bad I immediately went to an earlier save and redid the whole thing. Betrayed Reed and went with Songbird. It’s the only ending for me.
I went with songbird thinking to betray her later but at the end I couldn’t do it. I assumed the cure was bs and didn’t think pl would actually change the ending of the main game.
The fact that Reed counts to 3 I took to mean he really wants V to shoot first and song to go free. Reed from the baseball court would have fired first
Help Song
Help Reed because I love the Erebus and it’s the only way to get it
i would never not go with songbird personally, but after finding out some of what happens if you go with reed, I feel like the pro-songbird missions/rewards are just wildly lame in comparison
I sided with reed cause song birds plan sounded half baked
Picked songbird
Went with Songbird and sent her to the moon on my first go around.
Although I personally prefer the Reed route personally. Just absolutely love everything to do with raiding a Maxtac Convoy, and the absolute horror you find in that Cynosure Facility… The overall atmosphere in that place is so cool.
Plus it’s the most emotional of the two routes imo. Especially if you go with the King Of Cups ending. Which is the most fitting story wise for the Phantom Liberty Expansion.
So-Mi is a horrible person, regardless of the trauma, it doesnt justify the lengths she went. I happily betrayed her