Step 1: Pick up the Malorian when talking to Grayson.
Step 1 & 1/2: Shoot Grayson in the head.
Step 2: Go over to ladder to container control switch, climb up, press button.
Step 3: Go to lowered container.
Step 4: ???
Step 5: Profit
Or you can just tell Grayson you’ll spare his life, get the container location out of him, then shoot him. I.e., lie.
ANS__2009
Yes
Umibozu_CH
Absolutely. First, you agree to hear what Grayson has to offer, and then you shoot him anyway. Or, you just kill him and pick the loot up, then go check the container out.
baddorox
trick question?
LuziferTsumibito
I didn’t know you can’t have both tbh
b4stel
I have both – so yes, dont know why tho, had lot of single malt during my first playthrough
Sculpdozer
I have both malorian and porsche and have not killed grayson. Malorian was in my third equipment slot after the quest, when I checked.
LockenCharlie
I got both in both runs I did. It’s not that hard.
GnomeNot
I’ve never not gotten both.
Deathstroke5289
Just kill the dude and take the car
PakRatJR
I’ve always got both in all my playthroughs. I actually didn’t know it was possible to not get both?
doxtorwhom
You’re supposed to have both.
aclark210
Oh yeah. Get both every time. It’s easy as hell.
Schmillly
Idk if I’m missing something but I did 3 different playthroughs and always got both. I didn’t know it was possible to miss one?
Mary_Ellen_Katz
Um, yeah. I don’t think there’s been a run where I didn’t have both. I’m trying to figure out how you don’t without deliberately not picking them up.
dc010
I didn’t know I was supposed to pick. Figured it was logical to get what you could out of him before shooting him.
KainDracula
I have never not gotten both, and I have spared and killed him on different plays.
BadIDK
I’ve always had both, just tell Grayson you’ll spare him and he gives you the location of the car and gun gets dropped before hand. You can shoot Grayson afterward. Sometimes the crosshair doesn’t let you shoot so use the melee attack which sweeps and kills him
fellipec
Fam, I always got both, since the first time. Isn’t a choice you have to do.
Lord_Dankston
Huh? I’ve had both on every run so far
Succulent_Pigeon
Bro have you played the game just get the gun and spare grayson
mg932
Seeing this post had me thinking I was tripping, because I usually did end up getting both. Seeing the comments though has calmed me lol..
papa_commie
I don’t get it, it’s not like you choose, you can grab the Malorian from Grayson without a problem and you can get the car just as easily
vlad_kushner
??? I played normal and i got both…
JhulaeD
Yes, you can get both, as well as Johnny’s outfit. So, when you dress up like Johnny, use his gun, and drive his car, then look back at yourself it leans into that “I really *am* turning into Johnny” feel.
Tarushdei
Nothing is stopping you from shooting someone after agreeing to spare their life.
It comes up a couple other times in the game.
Olgrateful-IW
I didn’t know you couldn’t because I always got them both lol.
shibbington
How do you not get the gun during this mission? Don’t they just hand it to you when you interrogate Grayson? Do they take it back or something?
Juken-
Didn’t even know this was an issue, 6 playthroughs complete…
30 Comments
I don’t see why you can’t have both
Yes.
Step 1: Pick up the Malorian when talking to Grayson.
Step 1 & 1/2: Shoot Grayson in the head.
Step 2: Go over to ladder to container control switch, climb up, press button.
Step 3: Go to lowered container.
Step 4: ???
Step 5: Profit
Or you can just tell Grayson you’ll spare his life, get the container location out of him, then shoot him. I.e., lie.
Yes
Absolutely. First, you agree to hear what Grayson has to offer, and then you shoot him anyway. Or, you just kill him and pick the loot up, then go check the container out.
trick question?
I didn’t know you can’t have both tbh
I have both – so yes, dont know why tho, had lot of single malt during my first playthrough
I have both malorian and porsche and have not killed grayson. Malorian was in my third equipment slot after the quest, when I checked.
I got both in both runs I did. It’s not that hard.
I’ve never not gotten both.
Just kill the dude and take the car
I’ve always got both in all my playthroughs. I actually didn’t know it was possible to not get both?
You’re supposed to have both.
Oh yeah. Get both every time. It’s easy as hell.
Idk if I’m missing something but I did 3 different playthroughs and always got both. I didn’t know it was possible to miss one?
Um, yeah. I don’t think there’s been a run where I didn’t have both. I’m trying to figure out how you don’t without deliberately not picking them up.
I didn’t know I was supposed to pick. Figured it was logical to get what you could out of him before shooting him.
I have never not gotten both, and I have spared and killed him on different plays.
I’ve always had both, just tell Grayson you’ll spare him and he gives you the location of the car and gun gets dropped before hand. You can shoot Grayson afterward. Sometimes the crosshair doesn’t let you shoot so use the melee attack which sweeps and kills him
Fam, I always got both, since the first time. Isn’t a choice you have to do.
Huh? I’ve had both on every run so far
Bro have you played the game just get the gun and spare grayson
Seeing this post had me thinking I was tripping, because I usually did end up getting both. Seeing the comments though has calmed me lol..
I don’t get it, it’s not like you choose, you can grab the Malorian from Grayson without a problem and you can get the car just as easily
??? I played normal and i got both…
Yes, you can get both, as well as Johnny’s outfit. So, when you dress up like Johnny, use his gun, and drive his car, then look back at yourself it leans into that “I really *am* turning into Johnny” feel.
Nothing is stopping you from shooting someone after agreeing to spare their life.
It comes up a couple other times in the game.
I didn’t know you couldn’t because I always got them both lol.
How do you not get the gun during this mission? Don’t they just hand it to you when you interrogate Grayson? Do they take it back or something?
Didn’t even know this was an issue, 6 playthroughs complete…
Ya gotta read and pay attention man.